Automatic Transmission Troubles: 5 Warning Signs Your Gearbox Needs Attention

Is your car shifting funny or making new noises and having Automatic Transmission Troubles? Don’t ignore it. We highlight 5 common warning signs of automatic transmission problems. Let’s go through it.

1. Slipping Gears (Engine Revs But Car Doesn’t Accelerate): One of the most noticeable signs of transmission trouble is “slipping.” You press the gas, the engine revs higher than usual, but the car barely increases speed or feels like it’s not in the right gear. It can feel as if the transmission briefly “disengages” and then re-engages. You might also notice erratic shifting – the car may suddenly shift to a lower gear for no reason or have trouble staying in the intended gear. Slipping often occurs when the transmission’s internal clutches or bands are worn out or if there’s insufficient transmission fluid pressure. In fact, a common cause is low fluid level or degraded fluid, which leads to inadequate hydraulic pressure to keep the transmission in gear​

If your vehicle is experiencing slipping, it’s a serious warning sign. In addition to the sensation, you might smell a burnt odor – overheating fluid due to slipping can smell burnt. The check engine light or a specific transmission warning light may also illuminate. Don’t ignore this: continued driving with a slipping transmission can rapidly wear out components. Get the fluid level and condition checked first​

A fluid top-up or change, along with fixing any leak causing low fluid, might resolve minor slipping. In more severe cases, slipping gears could indicate the need for a transmission rebuild or replacement of worn clutch packs.

2. Delayed or Rough Shifting: Does your car take a few extra seconds to shift into drive after you put it in D? Or maybe when it shifts between gears, it bangs or jerks instead of transitioning smoothly. These are classic symptoms of transmission distress. A delayed engagement (especially noticeable when shifting from Park into Drive or Reverse) often points to low fluid or a failing internal seal, causing pressure loss​

Essentially, the transmission hesitates as it builds enough pressure to engage the gear. Rough shifts, on the other hand, where you feel a jolt or clunk during gear changes, could indicate a variety of issues: from worn transmission mounts (allowing excess movement) to sticky hydraulic valves or solenoids in the transmission valve body. Modern automatics rely on electronic solenoids to route fluid for gear changes; if one is malfunctioning, shifts can become harsh or occur at odd times. Another culprit for harsh shifting can be old transmission fluid that’s become too thick or contaminated, or fluid that’s lost its frictional properties. In any case, a healthy transmission should shift almost imperceptibly. If yours is making itself known with jolts or delays, have it looked at soon. Sometimes a transmission software update (reflashing the control module) can address shift issues, if it’s a known calibration problem. Otherwise, a fluid and filter change is a good first step. Persistent problems may mean internal wear or an issue with the valve body that may require repair or replacement.

​

3. Strange Noises – Whining, Grinding, or Clunking: Unusual sounds are a car’s way of crying for help. For automatics, a whining noise that increases with engine RPM could mean several things. A common source is a failing transmission pump or low fluid causing the pump to cavitate (essentially sucking air) – this often produces a telltale whine. If the whining is loudest in certain gears or only when moving, it could be a worn gear set or torque converter issue. A grinding or buzzing noise might occur if internal metal parts like bearings are worn or if clutches are grinding themselves down due to lack of fluid. On the other hand, a pronounced clunk when shifting into drive or reverse could point to either a transmission issue or even something like a bad universal joint or CV joint in the driveline. However, multiple clunks during normal gear shifts usually indicate transmission distress, possibly a bad solenoid or accumulator. One thing to check: does the noise happen when the car is in neutral and you rev the engine? If you hear a whining in neutral that goes away in park, that can specifically suggest a worn transmission component (since in neutral the pump is active). Meanwhile, a constant grinding noise while driving that changes with speed might be more related to axle or wheel bearings – so it’s important to localize the noise. If you suspect the transmission is whining or grinding, have the fluid inspected. Fluid contaminated with metal shavings (often visible as a glimmer in the fluid or collected on the pan magnet) is a sign of internal wear​

Additionally, a mechanic can perform a diagnostic scan; many modern transmissions will log fault codes if solenoids slip or pressures are out of spec, which can accompany noises. Ignoring these noises is not wise – a minor bearing whine can turn into a major failure if not addressed. Sometimes a simple bearing or component can be replaced if caught early, but if left, it could necessitate a full rebuild.

4. Leaking Red Fluid Under the Car: Transmission fluid (for automatics) is usually a red or pinkish color (sometimes brownish if very old/dirty). If you notice a puddle or drops of red fluid under your parked car, that’s almost certainly transmission fluid (unless you have power steering fluid or coolant that happens to be red, but those are less common in red). Automatic transmissions are closed systems, so they should never “use up” fluid – if it’s low, it has leaked out somewhere. Common leak points include the pan gasket (especially if someone did a fluid change and didn’t replace the gasket or properly torque the pan bolts), the axle seals where CV axles enter the transaxle, the front pump seal (which can leak where the torque converter connects – often this leaks when the car is running and drips out of the bellhousing area), or cooler lines that carry fluid to the transmission cooler in the radiator. A small leak might not immediately cause issues, but over time even a small drip can lower fluid to the point of causing the aforementioned slipping or harsh shifts. If you spot a leak, check your transmission fluid dipstick (if the car has one) to see if the level is dropping. Also observe the fluid color – healthy fluid is translucent red and has a somewhat sweet or mild chemical odor. Burnt-smelling or dark, opaque fluid indicates it’s overdue for a change or has been overheating​

What to do: Get leaks repaired sooner rather than later. Replacing a pan gasket or seal is much cheaper than rebuilding a transmission ruined by low fluid. Even if you don’t see a drip, sometimes you might smell burned fluid after driving (a leak that hits exhaust parts can burn off and smell). Don’t ignore signs of leaks; an automatic transmission cannot function properly without the correct fluid volume and pressure.

5. Check Engine Light (or Transmission Warning Light): Many people don’t realize, but the check engine light (CEL) often illuminates for transmission-related issues as well. Modern vehicles have sensors throughout the transmission. If the computer detects something like excessive slipping, long shift times, or solenoid electrical faults, it will likely trigger the CEL. Some cars also have a dedicated transmission warning light (often depicted as a gear symbol). If your CEL comes on and the car is exhibiting any of the symptoms above (slipping, hard shifts, etc.), it’s likely the onboard diagnostics have picked up the problem. For example, a code like P0700 is a general transmission control system fault (often accompanied by more specific codes logged in the transmission control module). Codes like P0730-series indicate gear ratio errors (meaning the transmission isn’t achieving the expected gear ratio – a sign of slipping)​

There are also codes for solenoid malfunctions, pressure out-of-range, etc. The presence of a warning light should prompt a scan with an OBD-II scanner to retrieve these codes. This will significantly narrow down the issue. For instance, a “torque converter clutch circuit” code could explain why you feel shuddering at highway speeds (when the converter clutch tries to lock). Or a “shift solenoid B stuck off” code might correlate with your 3rd gear slipping issue. In essence, that little light could be your best friend in diagnosing the problem – so don’t just unplug the battery to reset it and hope for the best. Use it as a clue. And importantly, when a transmission is having serious issues, some cars will go into “limp mode” – this is a fail-safe where the transmission might lock itself in 3rd gear to limit damage (you’ll notice the car feels sluggish from a stop and won’t shift gears). If that happens, the car is telling you it needs immediate attention. Limp mode often comes with a warning light and is impossible to ignore as the car drives very differently.

What to Do If You Notice These Signs: If you encounter any of the above issues, the first step is to check the transmission fluid (if accessible). Low or dirty fluid is at the root of many transmission problems​

​

Topping off might provide temporary relief, but finding out where the fluid went is key. Next, avoid heavy driving; gentle use or not driving at all until fixed is prudent – you don’t want to push a marginal transmission into a complete failure. Schedule a visit to a trusted mechanic or transmission specialist. For some simpler cases, a transmission service (fluid and filter change) can alleviate issues, especially if the fluid is very old. However, be aware that if the transmission is severely worn, just changing fluid sometimes won’t help and, in rare cases, fresh very slippery fluid can exacerbate slipping (this is a debated topic, but generally fresh fluid is beneficial; just manage expectations if the trans is on its last legs).

Finally, catching problems early can save a lot of money. Replacing a solenoid or seal is far cheaper than a full rebuild. Transmissions often give warning signs before catastrophic failure – those noises, slips, and leaks are the transmission asking for help. Heed the warnings, and you might avoid being stranded on the side of the road with a gearbox that gave up the ghost.

Buying a used VW. Buying used vauxhall, BMW, Jaguar, Ford, Volvo, Range rover, Bentley, Aston Martin, Porsche, Ferrari, Lamborghini, Maserati, Hyundai, Tesla, Honda, Pagani